« BANK OWNED OR ABANDONED HOA PROPERTY FALLS INTO DISREPAIR - WHAT TO DO? | Main | Who Chooses Officers in an HOA? »
July 14, 2008
WHO DO THEY THINK THEY ARE - TELLING ME WHAT TO TAKE DOWN?
Sometimes one wonders all of the whys and the wherefores. Especially when they hear only one side of the story.
Here is a recent post from a reader (and see my answer in italics following the questions):
"There is an enclosed balcony in my condo with two open air windows. The
space was unusable due to high winds and salt off the sea. So I built very tasteful clear vinyl wind blocks so I could use the space, very similar to blinds, but clear. I thought this was okay.
Earlier, I had met with the owners of the condo and mentioned I was thinking of putting up something there to block the wind. They said they thought if I didn't put up a big sign with a slogan on it or something that it would be ok.
Within a very short time after putting up the wind blocks, I got a letter from the management company saying the wind blocks violate hoa rules andt they tell me they need to be taken down right away.
Do I have to comply even though I did not enter into a contract with the hoa? If I don't take them down, and there are fines against the owners, willm y rental insurance pay for it? The rental insurance includes legal fees if I am sued.
If I leave them up temporarily or permanently, can you see what problems that might cause?"
First of all, I would be asking the question: If the windblocks are clear and cannot be seen without close scrutiny, why object to their presence? It seems obvious in areas by the coast or otherwise subject to high winds that windbreaks are often needed to allow people to fully enjoy the outdoor spaces adjacent to their living units. One sees them everywhere. Just take a walk along the coast in Carmel or Monterey.
I can understand if the Board would be concerned about deteriorating, scratched or discolored windbreaks or mismatched or patchwork styling, but standards can be adopted for consistency and windbreaks that become a hazard or eyesore can be ordered removed or replaced, with penalties for failure to do so. So I invite the readers to tell me what a good reason is to disallow windbreaks in a situation like this (so I can be informed).
That said, the Condo Board does have the legal authority to set and enforce rules and the rules are presumed reasonable and enforceable unless an owner can (essentially) prove they are against the good of or harmful to the community as a whole (in very loosely paraphrased legal terms). That is a tough burden to meet.
Any disciplinary action would normally be rendered against an owner for a renter's conduct (or misconduct, violation of the rules and regulations, etc.) so it is up to an owner to deal with a tenant who creates a situation where penalties are being considered. Of course, a landlord owner can write into their lease (and should, for their own protection), that if the renter violates the rules or regulations of the Condo Association and there are any penalties involved, the renter has to reimburse the owner, and can (and definitely should) include a clause that says if a renter violates the rules and regulations, that is grounds for the owner to terminate the lease. That probably does not sound helpful to this renter who asked the questions, but it is the way it should be.
Now, for the questions about what can happen if a violation continues.
If the documents allow, and California law has been followed with regard to the processes required, fines might be imposed. If the Condo Board has to get legal assistance and the documents allow, and California law has been followed with regard to the processes required, reimbursement assessments might be imposed. The latter, if unpaid, could lead to liens and such, and possibly even foreclosure, so the penalties can be severe.
I wonder if this renter is not telling me something, like any reason given by the Condo Board for not allowing windbreaks. I wonder if you out there can tell me why a Board would not look for some options in this regard to offer owners (at their own expense) in properties subject to high winds?????
I feel the need to be enlightened on this one.
As to renter's insurance, it is very important to have. However, I do not know of any that pays for fines or legal defense for taking action that one knows is likely to lead to fines or legal action.
Posted by Beth Grimm at July 14, 2008 10:26 PM